CIAgent
88a1dab810
---ci--- phase: 7 milestone: v0.2 status: complete requirements: covered: [REQ-2-001, REQ-2-002, REQ-2-003, REQ-2-004, REQ-2-005, REQ-2-006, REQ-2-007, REQ-2-008, REQ-2-009, REQ-2-010, REQ-2-011, REQ-2-012] partial: [] ---/ci--- Milestone v0.2 (ai-tutor-architecture) merged to main. Escalation record (audit remediation, durable): P1 executor delegation failed twice (empty subagent results, zero files created); auto-resolved at full autonomy to inline execution with identical plan fidelity (commit 3271373, reflog-only after phase branch squash-delete).
36 lines
3.3 KiB
Markdown
36 lines
3.3 KiB
Markdown
# Nextcraft v0.2 — GRILL.md (Adversarial Review Verdict)
|
|
|
|
**Stage:** GRILL, Phase 0 pre-execution · **Verdict:** GO-WITH-CHANGES · **Confidence:** 0.82
|
|
|
|
## Per-Axis Findings
|
|
|
|
| Axis | Verdict | Rationale |
|
|
|------|---------|-----------|
|
|
| Feasibility | PASS | Environment claims verified (venv works, all 8 pinned packages on PyPI for py3.11, port 8420 free, secrets gitignored). Stall points pre-mitigated (idempotent bootstrap, 300s read timeout, idempotent abort; reactStrictMode confirmed in next.config). |
|
|
| Over-scoping | CONCERN (mild) | 4-layer JSON defense justified; 500-cap LRU is over-spec but cheap — keep, extend no further. Real gaps: no Python lint (fixed via G-3), cache dirs in gitignore (fixed), script path resolution (advisory c). |
|
|
| Architecture risk | CONCERN | sse-starlette `: ping` frames invisible to short TestClient streams — parser gap fixed via G-1. Agent registration had two contradictory patterns — fixed via G-4. Cloud outage blast radius contained by mock-only tests. |
|
|
| Phase sequencing | PASS | Integration-last correct: P1 freezes the SSE contract before client code exists; A-002 eliminates dev-server buffering trap. P4 heaviest but mechanical. |
|
|
| Verification honesty | CONCERN | Persona distinctness circular against self-authored mocks (disclosed; cloud probe optional). P6 must-haves manual-only. D-021 ID alignment unmechanized (advisory b). Disclosed honestly. |
|
|
| Cost/quota | PASS | Cloud burn bounded (~<100K tokens milestone-wide, manual probes only). Mock-only rule structurally enforced; mechanical guard via advisory (a). |
|
|
| Milestone honesty | PASS (conditional) | Mock-engine caveats present everywhere that matters. Release note content now bound by G-5; dead `aiTutorResponses` disposal bound by G-5. |
|
|
|
|
## Binding Decisions (applied to PLAN.md/ROADMAP.md)
|
|
|
|
- **G-1 (BINDING):** SSE frame parser in Task 6-1-01 must ignore frames with no `data:` lines (sse-starlette ping keep-alive). Added to Action + Phase 6 must-have.
|
|
- **G-2 (BINDING):** P6 end-to-end verification may run with `AI_PROVIDER=mock` fallback — real ai-service over HTTP is the requirement; provider choice is service-internal. Prevents cloud outage blocking P6.
|
|
- **G-3 (BINDING):** ruff (check-only) added: Task 1-1-04, pyproject dev extra, scripts/lint.sh, root `ai:lint`, turbo `ai#lint`, Phase 1 must-have.
|
|
- **G-4 (BINDING):** Mentor/Proctor registered centrally in `registry.py` (single registration pattern), matching P3/P4.
|
|
- **G-5 (BINDING):** v0.2.0 release note must state Lab/Assessor/Proctor run on mock engine inputs (v0.3+ for real); dead `aiTutorResponses` export disposed of in P7.
|
|
|
|
## Advisory (non-binding; applied where cheap)
|
|
|
|
- (a) conftest asserts provider is MockProvider — **applied in P1 implementation**
|
|
- (b) pytest reads packages/mock-data as text, asserts corpus IDs appear — **applied in P4 implementation**
|
|
- (c) scripts resolve repo root via script-relative dirname — **folded into Task 1-1-04/1-1-03**
|
|
- (d) `.pytest_cache/` + `.ruff_cache/` in .gitignore — **applied**
|
|
- (e) keep LRU as-is; no further session-store sophistication in v0.2
|
|
- (f) Task 6-2-02 REQ tag fixed to REQ-2-011 (routing) — **applied**
|
|
|
|
## Outcome
|
|
|
|
GO — all five binding decisions applied to PLAN.md/ROADMAP.md/.gitignore/ARCHITECTURE.md before Phase 1 execution. No axis requires escalation. |