Files
nextcraft/apps/ai-service/tests/api/test_defense.py
T
CIAgent 22d4fa212c fix(P05): verifier P0s — browser descriptor served, 409 post-finish, 422 empty audio, verdict persisted
Four gaps found by independent verifier probing of the defense endpoints
(all Must-Have-relevant, all trivially fixed):

1. Browser-mode descriptor was dead code: BROWSER_FALLBACK_DESCRIPTOR
   existed but start always returned mode='mock' even with
   AI_VOICE_PROVIDER=browser (Must-Have #6 violated). start now derives
   the descriptor from settings.voice_provider (D-030).
2. answer after finish returned 200 and appended turns to a sealed
   transcript — the store explicitly assigns sequencing to the endpoints
   (defense_store.py: 'turns after finalize are a sequencing bug for the
   endpoints to prevent, task 5-3-01'); the endpoints didn't. Now 409.
3. Zero-byte audio upload crashed the mock provider (MockVoiceFailure ->
   500); a real provider would 500 the same way. Empty upload is a client
   error: 422 before any provider call (provider contract unchanged).
4. Verdict was NOT persisted (Must-Have #1 'verdict + transcript
   persisted'): finish persisted only signals; GET after finish could not
   re-serve the verdict. The verdict now nests in integrity_signals
   (JSON-object dict per the DefenseStore.finalize contract).

3 regression tests added (empty-audio 422, post-finish 409, verdict
retrievable from GET; browser-descriptor test). Suite 386 green; ruff clean.

---ci---
phase: 5
milestone: v0.3
status: verify
requirements:
  covered: [REQ-3-006]
  partial: []
lessons:
  - A descriptor that exists but is never served is indistinguishable from
    dead code until you probe the configured mode end-to-end (factory tests
    proved selection, not service).
  - Store contracts that 'assign' sequencing to callers need an endpoint
    test for the forbidden transition, or the assignment is decorative.
---/ci---
2026-09-12 04:49:46 +00:00

235 lines
9.8 KiB
Python

"""Defense endpoint tests (Task 5-3-01, REQ-3-006) — mock voice + mock LLM."""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
from pathlib import Path
import pytest
from fastapi.testclient import TestClient
from ai_service.agents.examiner import ExaminerAgent
from ai_service.config import Settings
from ai_service.grading.store import SQLiteGradeStore
from ai_service.llm.mock import MockProvider
from ai_service.main import create_app
from ai_service.telemetry.ingest import TraceIntegrityMap
from ai_service.telemetry.store import SQLiteTraceStore
from ai_service.variants.store import SQLiteVariantStore
from ai_service.voice.defense_store import SQLiteDefenseStore
from ai_service.voice.mock import MockVoiceProvider
VERDICT = {
"verdict": "developing",
"understanding": "Explains the build clearly.",
"process_justification": "Justifies choices.",
"communication": "Clear and specific.",
"strengths": ["Grounded answers in the digest."],
"gaps": ["Did not address the edge cases."],
}
class ScriptedLLM(MockProvider):
"""Question-mode calls get a question; verdict-mode calls get D-020 JSON.
Discriminator: the verdict prompt contains "final verdict JSON" — the
question prompt says "next question".
"""
def __init__(self) -> None:
super().__init__()
async def chat(self, messages, *, model, temperature=0.7, response_format=None):
all_text = "\n".join(m.content for m in messages)
if "final verdict JSON" in all_text:
return json.dumps(VERDICT)
return "Why did you structure the fix that way?"
@pytest.fixture()
def app(tmp_path: Path):
application = create_app(Settings(provider="mock", voice_provider="mock"))
llm = ScriptedLLM()
application.state.provider = llm
application.state.trace_store = SQLiteTraceStore(db_path=tmp_path / "t.db")
application.state.variant_store = SQLiteVariantStore(db_path=tmp_path / "v.db")
application.state.grade_store = SQLiteGradeStore(db_path=tmp_path / "g.db")
application.state.trace_integrity = TraceIntegrityMap()
application.state.defense_store = SQLiteDefenseStore(db_path=tmp_path / "d.db")
application.state.voice_provider = MockVoiceProvider(
["the fix was in the retry loop"]
)
settings = Settings(provider="mock", voice_provider="mock")
application.state.examiner_agent = ExaminerAgent(llm, settings)
return application
@pytest.fixture()
def client(app) -> TestClient:
with TestClient(app) as c:
yield c
def _start(client: TestClient) -> dict:
resp = client.post(
"/v1/defense/start", json={"learner_id": "defense-learner", "task_id": "defense-task"}
)
assert resp.status_code == 200, resp.text
return resp.json()
class TestStart:
def test_start_returns_first_question_and_descriptor(self, client) -> None:
body = _start(client)
assert body["first_question"]
assert body["defense_id"]
assert body["voice_descriptor"]["mode"] == "mock"
assert body["trace_complete"] is True
stored = client.get(f"/v1/defense/{body['defense_id']}")
assert stored.status_code == 200
turns = stored.json()["turns"]
assert turns and turns[0]["role"] == "examiner"
def test_start_with_unknown_trace_is_complete_flag(self, client) -> None:
body = _start(client)
assert body["trace_complete"] is True
class TestBrowserFallback:
def test_browser_mode_serves_browser_descriptor(self, tmp_path: Path) -> None:
"""Must-Have #6: AI_VOICE_PROVIDER=browser → start returns the
browser-native SR/TTS fallback descriptor (D-030), not 'mock'."""
application = create_app(Settings(provider="mock", voice_provider="browser"))
application.state.provider = ScriptedLLM()
application.state.trace_store = SQLiteTraceStore(db_path=tmp_path / "t.db")
application.state.variant_store = SQLiteVariantStore(db_path=tmp_path / "v.db")
application.state.grade_store = SQLiteGradeStore(db_path=tmp_path / "g.db")
application.state.trace_integrity = TraceIntegrityMap()
application.state.defense_store = SQLiteDefenseStore(db_path=tmp_path / "d.db")
application.state.voice_provider = MockVoiceProvider(["answer"])
llm = ScriptedLLM()
application.state.examiner_agent = ExaminerAgent(
llm, Settings(provider="mock", voice_provider="browser")
)
with TestClient(application) as c:
body = _start(c)
assert body["voice_descriptor"]["mode"] == "browser"
assert body["voice_descriptor"]["sr_available"]
assert "SpeechRecognition" in body["voice_descriptor"]["hint"]
class TestAnswer:
def test_typed_answer_yields_followup_with_latency(self, client) -> None:
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
resp = client.post(
f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer", data={"text": "I fixed the loop."}
)
assert resp.status_code == 200, resp.text
body = resp.json()
assert body["question"]
assert body["turn_latency"]["llm_ms"] is not None
def test_audio_answer_transcribed_and_recorded(self, client) -> None:
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
wav_bytes = b"RIFF" + b"\x00" * 64
resp = client.post(
f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer",
files={"audio": ("answer.wav", wav_bytes, "audio/wav")},
)
assert resp.status_code == 200, resp.text
stored = client.get(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}").json()
learner_turns = [t for t in stored["turns"] if t["role"] == "learner"]
assert learner_turns, "learner turn missing after audio answer"
assert learner_turns[0]["text"] == "the fix was in the retry loop"
def test_empty_audio_is_422_not_500(self, client) -> None:
"""Zero-byte upload must 422 before the provider call (a real
provider would raise the same way the mock does — validate first)."""
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
resp = client.post(
f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer",
files={"audio": ("answer.wav", b"", "audio/wav")},
)
assert resp.status_code == 422, resp.text
stored = client.get(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}").json()
assert len(stored["turns"]) == 1 # nothing appended
def test_answer_after_finish_is_409(self, client) -> None:
"""A sealed transcript is append-only-no-more: the endpoints own
turn-vs-finalize sequencing (defense_store contract)."""
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer", data={"text": "a"})
assert client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/finish").status_code == 200
resp = client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer", data={"text": "late"})
assert resp.status_code == 409, resp.text
stored = client.get(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}").json()
assert len(stored["turns"]) == 3 # ex, lrn, ex — no post-finish turns
def test_neither_text_nor_audio_422(self, client) -> None:
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
resp = client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer")
assert resp.status_code == 422
def test_unknown_defense_404(self, client) -> None:
resp = client.post("/v1/defense/dfn-nope/answer", data={"text": "hi"})
assert resp.status_code == 404
class TestAudioEndpoint:
def test_examiner_turn_streams_wav(self, client) -> None:
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
resp = client.get(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/audio/0")
assert resp.status_code == 200
assert resp.content
assert resp.headers["content-type"].startswith("audio/")
def test_unknown_turn_404(self, client) -> None:
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
assert client.get(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/audio/42").status_code == 404
class TestFinishAndGet:
def test_full_loop_verdict_and_signals(self, client) -> None:
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/answer", data={"text": "answer one"})
finish = client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/finish")
assert finish.status_code == 200, finish.text
body = finish.json()
assert body["verdict"]["verdict"] == "developing"
assert body["integrity_signals"]["pause_threshold_ms"]
stored = client.get(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}").json()
assert stored["status"] == "finished"
assert stored["integrity_signals"]
# Must-Have #1: "verdict + transcript persisted" — the verdict must
# be retrievable from GET after finish, not only in the finish body.
assert stored["integrity_signals"]["verdict"]["verdict"] == "developing"
def test_long_pause_flagged(self, client, app) -> None:
from datetime import UTC, datetime
from ai_service.voice.defense_store import DefenseTurn
defense_id = _start(client)["defense_id"]
# inject a slow learner turn directly (simulated latency)
store = app.state.defense_store
store.append_turn(
defense_id,
DefenseTurn(
defense_id=defense_id,
seq=99,
role="learner",
text="slow reply",
ts=datetime.now(UTC),
latency_ms=30_000,
created_at=datetime.now(UTC),
),
)
finish = client.post(f"/v1/defense/{defense_id}/finish")
assert finish.status_code == 200
signals = finish.json()["integrity_signals"]
assert any(p["turn"] == 99 for p in signals["long_pauses"])
def test_unknown_defense_404_on_all(self, client) -> None:
assert client.post("/v1/defense/dfn-nope/finish").status_code == 404
assert client.get("/v1/defense/dfn-nope").status_code == 404