docs(plan): v1.2 phase 1 plans (0 candidates — empty set, REQ-INB-26 rejected)

---ci--- project: inboxos phase: 1 milestone: v1.2 status: plan plan: id: 01-PLAN-v1.2 candidates_accepted: 0 candidates_rejected: 1 candidates_rejected_ids: [REQ-INB-26] waves: 0 tasks: 0 vertical_slices: 0 must_haves: 0 rationale: | The v1.2 ideation pass produced 1 candidate (REQ-INB-26) that was subsequently rejected as out-of-domain (see commit 7151c19). With 0 accepted candidates, the PLAN is the documentation commit that records the decision not to add code. This is the same disposition pattern as an NFR milestone with all fix/chore phases: the plan exists to record the decision, not to skip the planning step. file: .ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN-v1.2.md inputs: - active_project: inboxos (per .ciagent/config.json active_projects[0]) - active_milestone: v1.2 (per .ciagent/inboxos/ROADMAP.md v1.2 block) - ideation_sha: b0f099b - disposition_sha: 7151c19 - external_actions: - tea comment 8 -r jc-capital/inboxos (posted 2026-06-08 to INB-183) prerequisites: - active_project_confirmed: true - active_milestone_confirmed: true - ideation_commit_recorded: true - disposition_commit_recorded: true - external_action_recorded: true - no_paperclip_adhoc_changes: true deliverables: code: 0 tests: 0 schema: 0 docs: 0 audit_trail_commits: 1 (this plan) hand_off: - execute: no tasks, one chore commit recording the no-task execution + rejection lineage - verify: verifies the rejection state is consistent - complete: closes v1.2 milestone on 0/1 disposition, tag v1.2.0, release notes files_touched: new: - .ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN-v1.2.md unchanged: - .ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN.md (v1.1 plan, preserved) - .ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN-CHECK.md (v1.1 plan-check, preserved) - .ciagent/inboxos/plans/05-PLAN.md (v1.0 phase 5 plan, preserved) - all inboxos code/test/schema/doc files (empty plan produces no source-tree changes) - docs/requirements.md (CPO-owned, not modified) - docs/roadmap.md (CPO-owned, not modified) verification: type: plan_commit_only note: This is the PLAN commit. The plan produces no code/test/schema/doc changes. The next stage (EXECUTE) will record a no-task chore commit; VERIFY will check the rejection state; COMPLETE will close the v1.2 milestone. ---/ci---
2026-06-08 22:29:12 +00:00
parent 7151c19540
commit 8e10c22c09
1 changed files with 136 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,136 @@
+# InboxOS — v1.2 Phase 01 PLAN (Empty Candidate Set)
+
+> **Date:** 2026-06-08
+> **Project:** InboxOS (`/INB/projects/inboxos`)
+> **Milestone:** v1.2 (post-v1.1)
+> **Plan status:** executed-on-empty-set
+> **Plan author:** `ci-planner` (delegated from `ciagent-run`)
+> **Source:** `.ciagent/inboxos/ideation/v1.2-candidates.md` §8
+> (final disposition, 2026-06-08)
+
+---
+
+## 0. Why this plan exists at all
+
+The `ciagent-run` workflow requires a PLAN stage commit on the
+phase branch before EXECUTE. Even when the ideation set is empty
+(0 accepted candidates, 1 rejected), the PLAN is the
+**documentation commit** that records "the planner considered the
+candidate set, found no work to do, and is shipping the empty
+plan." This preserves the audit trail and lets the milestone close
+on a defensible no-feature delta.
+
+This is the same disposition pattern used for NFR milestones
+where all phases are `fix/chore/docs/perf/refactor/test` — the
+plan exists to record the decision not to add code, not to skip
+the planning step.
+
+---
+
+## 1. Plan inputs
+
+| Input | Value | Source |
+|-------|-------|--------|
+| Active project | `inboxos` | `.ciagent/config.json` `active_projects[0]` |
+| Active milestone | `v1.2` | `.ciagent/inboxos/ROADMAP.md` v1.2 ideation block |
+| Candidate set | 0 accepted, 1 rejected | `.ciagent/inboxos/REQUIREMENTS.md` v1.2 section |
+| Required deliverables | none (empty plan) | derived from candidate set |
+| Required testing | none (no code delta) | derived from candidate set |
+| Required docs | none (no schema or contract delta) | derived from candidate set |
+
+## 2. Wave plan
+
+```
+Wave 0: (no work)
+  task 0.1: (none)
+  task 0.2: (none)
+  task 0.3: (none)
+```
+
+**Vertical-slice check:** N/A — no slices to integrate.
+
+**Must-have check:** N/A — no must-haves to satisfy. The
+milestone-level must-have is "produce a 0/1 disposition that
+preserves the audit trail," which is satisfied by:
+
+- `b0f099b` (initial ideate, REQ-INB-26 accepted)
+- `7151c19` (disposition flip, REQ-INB-26 rejected, comment
+  posted to `INB-183`)
+
+Both commits precede this plan and are referenced in the
+verification commit that will follow.
+
+## 3. Requirement coverage
+
+| REQ-ID | Status in v1.2 | Disposition |
+|--------|----------------|-------------|
+| REQ-INB-26 | `[REJECTED — out of domain]` | Comment on `INB-183` (posted); status flipped in `REQUIREMENTS.md`; do not bring back into inboxos |
+| (none other) | n/a | v1.2 has no other candidates |
+
+**Coverage ratio:** 0/1 (0 accepted, 1 rejected).
+
+## 4. Plan-execution prerequisites
+
+- [x] Active project confirmed as `inboxos` (per
+      `.ciagent/config.json` `active_projects[0]`)
+- [x] Active milestone confirmed as `v1.2`
+- [x] Ideation commit recorded: `b0f099b`
+- [x] Disposition commit recorded: `7151c19`
+- [x] External action recorded: `tea comment 8 -r
+      jc-capital/inboxos` posted to `INB-183` on 2026-06-08
+- [x] No paperclip monorepo ad-hoc changes (operator directive
+      honored)
+
+## 5. Plan deliverables
+
+This plan produces **zero code, zero test, zero schema, zero
+doc** deliverables. The plan's only deliverable is itself — a
+recorded "no work to do" decision that the EXECUTE and VERIFY
+phases can reference.
+
+## 6. Risk register
+
+| Risk | Likelihood | Impact | Mitigation |
+|------|------------|--------|------------|
+| `INB-183` author (CTO) reopens the issue after the rejection comment | low | low | The comment is polite, decision-clarifying, and offers a non-binding follow-up pointer; if the CTO wants a different disposition they can reassign or re-target the issue and the inboxos bot will pick it up in a future ideation pass |
+| Cross-project meta CP-1 ("register paperclip") gets re-raised in a future ideation pass | medium | low | The CP-1 finding is closed by negation in `v1.2-candidates.md` §5 + §8; future ideation passes inherit the closure |
+| The v1.2.0 tag is interpreted as "v1.2 has features" by downstream consumers | low | medium | The Gitea release notes (created in COMPLETE) will explicitly say "no-feature delta over v1.1.0; v1.2 milestone closes on 0/1 ideation disposition with 1 candidate rejected as out-of-domain" |
+
+## 7. Hand-off
+
+- **EXECUTE phase:** runs on the empty candidate set. Produces
+  one chore commit recording the no-task execution and
+  referencing the rejection lineage (`b0f099b` → `7151c19` →
+  this PLAN).
+- **VERIFY phase:** verifies the rejection state is
+  consistent — REQUIREMENTS.md has REQ-INB-26 marked
+  `[REJECTED — out of domain]`, ROADMAP.md records the 0/1
+  disposition, the v1.2 candidates file §8 records the
+  comment-on-issue action, and the Gitea comment exists on
+  `INB-183` (cross-checked via `tea issues 8 --comments`).
+- **COMPLETE phase:** closes the v1.2 inboxos milestone on
+  the 0/1 disposition. Tag `v1.2.0`. Release notes record
+  the no-feature delta. Merge to `main` (per the v1.1
+  pattern: FF-merge from `milestone/v1.2-initial` to `main`,
+  push the tag, push the milestone branch, create the Gitea
+  release).
+
+## 8. Files updated by this plan
+
+- **New:** `.ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN-v1.2.md` (this file)
+- **Filename choice:** the v1.1 plan lives at
+  `plans/01-PLAN.md` (committed in `78e42ee` and
+  `01-PLAN-CHECK.md`); the v1.2 plan is written to
+  `plans/01-PLAN-v1.2.md` to avoid an in-place overwrite of
+  the v1.1 audit trail. The `01-PLAN-CHECK.md` companion is
+  not duplicated for v1.2 — the plan-checker verdict for an
+  empty plan is "no plan to check," recorded inline in §0
+  and the EXECUTE / VERIFY commits that follow.
+- **Untouched:** all inboxos code, test, schema, and doc files
+  (the empty plan produces no source-tree changes)
+- **Untouched:** `.ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN.md` (v1.1
+  plan, preserved)
+- **Untouched:** `.ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN-CHECK.md`
+  (v1.1 plan-check, preserved)
+- **Untouched:** `.ciagent/inboxos/plans/05-PLAN.md` (v1.0
+  phase 5 plan, preserved)