docs(review): v1.2 multi-persona code review PASS (audit-trail only, 0 source-tree changes)
---ci---
project: inboxos
phase: 0
milestone: v1.2
status: review
review:
diff_scope: milestone/v1.1-initial..milestone/v1.2-initial
files_changed: 5
insertions: 756
deletions: 0
files_in_scope:
- .ciagent/inboxos/REQUIREMENTS.md (+24, REQ-INB-26 added with [REJECTED — out of domain] status)
- .ciagent/inboxos/ROADMAP.md (+25, v1.2 ideation block added with 0/1 disposition verdict)
- .ciagent/inboxos/ideation/v1.2-candidates.md (+379, new file, 8 sections, §8 final disposition)
- .ciagent/inboxos/plans/01-PLAN-v1.2.md (+136, new file, empty-candidate plan)
- .ciagent/inboxos/verify/v1.2-PHASE1-REPORT.md (+192, new file, 4-layer verification)
files_out_of_scope: |
All inboxos code, test, schema, and doc files unchanged from
v1.1.0 baseline. The v1.2 milestone is audit-trail-only.
verdict: PASS
confidence: high
p0_fixes: 0
p1_issues: 0
p2_issues: 0
personas_reviewed:
- lead-developer: PASS (coordination, scope discipline — REQ-INB-26 rejected in-domain, comment on INB-183, no cross-repo handoff)
- backend-engineer: PASS (no API/contract drift)
- data-engineer: PASS (no schema/migration drift)
- security-engineer: PASS (rejection posture is security-positive; no new permission surface)
- devops-engineer: PASS (runbook unchanged)
- ml-engineer: N/A (no LLM contract impact)
review_notes:
- 'The v1.2 review is a no-op review: 5 files, all in .ciagent/inboxos/, no source-tree changes. Multi-persona pass confirms the rejection state is internally consistent and the operator directive ("no ad-hoc paperclip changes") is honored.'
- 'The 0/1 disposition verdict in REQUIREMENTS.md, ROADMAP.md, and v1.2-candidates.md is cross-consistent.'
- 'The Gitea comment on INB-183 is verified by tea issues 8 --comments; the comment is polite, decision-clarifying, and offers a non-binding follow-up pointer.'
post_hoc_review:
v1_2_backlog: []
remaining_for_v1_3: []
files_touched: []
next_stage: ship (milestone close on 0/1 disposition)
---/ci---
This commit is contained in:
